Conflict: . School and peers play a major role in the outcome of this conflict. Kids who get along well with other kids their age and who do well in school will emerge from this stage feeling competent. Those who aren't able to successfully navigate social interactions and academic challenges may end up feeling inferior and lack self-confidence.
Critique Critique Collins' didn't actually explain a universal scientific method
Material resources influence both dominant and subordinate class
Collin's rejects some micro levels of analysis that are important
Ruling class is not always at an advantage Conflict theory ignores order and stability.
Conflict theory has been criticized for being ideologically radical
Conflict theory is underdeveloped in comparison to other theories The Individuals that will be mentioned in this Presentation are:
-Randall Collins (emphasis on this theorist) Background of Theory and Theorist Background of Theory and Theorist Background of Theory and Theorist Background of Theory and Theorist Karl Marx
Karl Marx (1818-1883) was a German philosopher and economist, who was not a self-proclaimed sociologist.
Although Marx did not consider himself a sociologist, he had a profound impact on historical and contemporary sociological thought.
He is considered to be one of the founders of Sociology
Discussed about the Elite class and the Working class
The Capitalist class owns and controls the means of production, while they also see the distribution of the goods or services.
The Capitalist class is also known as the dominant group.
His second class, the working class, are the people who provide the labor necessary to produce the goods and services.
Karl Marx Conflict Theory Essay - 890 Words - …
Conflict:. During this last stage of Erikson's theory of psychosocial development, older people looking back on their lives who feel satisfied with all they've experienced and accomplished will emerge with a sense of wisdom and satisfaction.
Conflict theory - New World Encyclopedia
Conflict:. People want to feel they've contributed something to the world, and so successfully navigating this conflict involves accomplishments like raising a family, succeeding at work, and volunteering in the community. During this stage of middle adulthood, people who aren't able to do this often feel disconnected from the rest of the world.
Causes of Intractable Conflicts | Beyond Intractability
Collins believed that a conflict theory of stratification must examine the material arrangements that affect interaction
Actors are likely to be affected by material factors, but not in the same way
A major variable is the different resources actors posses
Actors with considerable material can resist or modify these material constraints, but those with fewer materials are determined by material settings
The Intractable Conflict Challenge
Collins made a firm commitment to the scientific study of stratification and every other aspect of the social world
Collins prescribed to several things Collins’ conflict sociology:
Giving and taking orders
The more one gives to orders, the more satisfied
The more one takes orders, the more one is socially disturbed
All in all, Collins was an advocate of the scientific study of small-scale social manifestations of social conflicts Major Ideas, Concepts & Themes Collins extended stratification to other social domains (sexes and age groups)
E.g., the family and male dominance
E.g., adult dominance over younger age group
Formal organizations are “arenas of struggle”
Coercion leads to avoidance of being coerced
Offering rewards is a preferable strategy
Collins is comparable to Dahrendorf
Collins provides a more integrative approach Relevance of Theory Today Application of the theory
Dominant group examples:
Subordinate group examples:
When it comes to criminal punishment,
Groups do not hold the same values or beliefs
Dominate groups seem to determine aspects of the law
However, subordinate groups are ostracized
Criminal punishment shows coercion of dominant group
For example, this is shown in the film by Michael Moore Relevance of Theory Today Academic Application
Multinational Corporations & Local Communites
Faculty Promotion and Tenure
Due to hierarchical systems
Real World Application
Can be applied to Capitalism
Power assertion can be physical, legal and economic
Continues to be class inequality
Conflict theory can have further applications
Conflict theory and Structural Functionalism could be integrated
Conflict (negative) can have positive results such as:
Conflict can solidify a loosely structured group
Conflict with one group can lead to alliances with another Critique Conflict can bring isolated passive citizens into an active role
Conflict increases communication
Conflict theory over represents the functions of conflict and fails to emphasize the dysfunction conflict induces Critique Collins ' theory states:
Violent conflict doesn't come easily or automatically
Only a small number of people are capable of being violent
How can this be true with the surge of violence in society?
Is Collins' research still accurate as society becomes more violent?